By Illie Massey, School Improvement Representative, Special Education Support
Classroom management is one of the biggest challenges teachers face early in their careers. Most new teachers come in with strong content knowledge and real care for their students. What they are still building is the day-to-day skill of running a classroom, and that takes time, practice, and good support.
I once visited a sixth-grade math class at a large urban middle school. The teacher is in his first year. He gave the directions for a partner activity entirely out loud, four steps in a row, and about a third of the room looked unsure before they even began.
Once students were working, he moved around the room. He crouched beside a multilingual student who was stuck, asked her to tell him what she had tried, and then said, “Say more about that part.” Her posture changed, and she began explaining her thinking with real confidence.
At the back of the room, a group of four had stopped working. He glanced at them twice, tensed, and turned back to the students he was already helping. Near the end of class, he asked for everyone’s attention three times, each a little louder, and the exit tickets were rushed.
After the bell, he said, “That was a rough one.” Then he added, “But she finally got it.”
What stayed with me is that his instincts for connection were strong, and that’s the foundation everything else rests on. What is missing are the routines: written directions, a plan for groups that drift off task, and a calmer way to signal for attention. He was inventing every system on his own while also teaching content, and he measures his day by moments of connection, which means the hard moments land heavily. Our job is to build on what is working and take some of that load off.
Start with safety and trust
Zaretta Hammond’s Culturally Responsive Teaching and the Brain gave me a useful way to think about moments like this one. Students learn best when they feel safe and connected, a brain on alert is not ready to take in new learning. Management, then, is less about control and more about building trust and predictable routines that let students take on challenging work. It also means holding high expectations while showing students, through steady care, that their teacher believes in them.
Here is what that can look like in practice.
The first minute of class. The teacher stands at the door and greets each student by name. A short task is already on the board, and it is the same kind of task every day, so students know exactly what to do the moment they sit down. There is no scramble and no waiting for instructions. The routine tells students that the room is organized, that they were expected, and that someone is glad they are there.
A warm but firm response to a hard moment. A student pushes back on a difficult assignment and says, “I can’t do this.” A teacher focused only on compliance might insist or send the student out. A teacher using what Hammond describes as a warm demander approach stays close and calm and says something like, “I know this is hard, and I’m not going to let you give up on it. Let’s do the first step together.” The expectation does not change, but the student feels supported while meeting it.
Positive and specific language. Small wording changes add up over a day. “Walk, please” works better than “Stop running.” “Pencils down and eyes on me in three, two, one” works better than “Quit talking.” Students hear what to do, not only what to stop, and the tone of the room stays calm.
In another classroom that same month, I saw what a calm response can do. Halfway through my observation, a student slammed his textbook shut and muttered something sharp at the student next to him. The room went quiet, waiting for the explosion.
The teacher didn’t call him out. She kept teaching, walked down his aisle, and placed a sticky note on his desk. I assume it asked him to meet her in the hallway. He got up and left, and a couple of minutes later he walked back in, sat down, and got to work on the worksheet.
Nothing about that moment was dramatic, and that’s what made it effective. She protected his dignity in front of his peers, kept the lesson moving for everyone else, and gave him a private place to reset. He came back ready to learn, and the class never lost its footing. That is the kind of trust and predictability Hammond describes, and it is built through routines a teacher has practiced well before the hard moment arrives.
Coach in small, practical steps
For school leaders, the next question is how to help a new teacher build these skills without overwhelming them. Paul Bambrick-Santoyo’s Get Better Faster makes a strong case for coaching that is frequent, focused, and practical. Rather than giving a new teacher a long list of things to fix, a leader picks one or two high-impact next steps and practices them together.
Here is how that can sound in a real feedback conversation.
Instead of: “Your directions were hard to follow, and the class got a little loud.”
Try: “Next week, let’s focus on one thing: the directions for partner work. Right now I’d like to practice with you. Give me the directions the way you’d give them to the class, and I’ll play a student. Let’s cut it down to three short steps and write them on the board so students can look back at them. I’ll stop by on Thursday to see how it goes, and we can talk for ten minutes afterward.”
That one exchange names a single priority, builds the skill through rehearsal rather than advice, sets a specific follow-up, and keeps the conversation focused on growth rather than judgment.
A few other small, specific action steps work well for early-career teachers:
- Write multi-step directions on the board or a slide, and say them aloud once
- Choose one calm signal for getting attention and practice it with students until it is automatic
- Decide ahead of time what you will do when a group drifts off task, such as a quiet check-in with a clear question to answer
- Visit a colleague’s classroom for fifteen minutes to watch one routine, then debrief together
Timing matters as much as content. While doing classroom walkthroughs with a school leader, I watched him give a teacher feedback in a way I have never forgotten. In the middle of her lesson, he noticed she was teaching something incorrectly. Rather than wait for a debrief days later, he stepped quietly to her side and gave her a brief, private note, without interrupting the lesson or drawing the students’ attention.
The change was small, but the impact was immediate. In her very next moves, she adjusted her instruction based on what he had said. She stopped teaching in error, and her students got the correct content in that same lesson instead of having to be retaught later.
What stayed with me was how much his delivery mattered. Because it was quiet and in the moment, it protected her dignity and her authority in front of her class, and it protected her students’ learning. It showed me that the most effective feedback is often timely, specific, and low-key.
Short, regular cycles of observing, giving feedback, and practicing help teachers improve faster, and they keep feedback from feeling like criticism.
Connecting to our work on restorative practices
Restorative approaches help repair relationships when harm occurs. Strong everyday management helps create the conditions where there is less harm to repair in the first place. Used together, they give schools both a way to prevent problems and a way to respond well when they happen.
Investing in new teachers pays off for students, for staff retention, and for the overall culture of a school.
Support from BCHF
Also, please remember at BCHF, we provide personalized professional development to meet the needs of each school. If classroom management is an area your teachers want to strengthen, reach out to your school improvement representative. They will be happy to design a PD session for you, or connect you with a specialist you can work with to build one around your school’s needs.
References
- Bambrick-Santoyo, P. (2016). Get Better Faster: A 90-Day Plan for Coaching New Teachers. Jossey-Bass.
- Hammond, Z. (2015). Culturally Responsive Teaching and the Brain. Corwin.
